‘Wanted,’ The Rousing, Sonorous Musical Makes its Broadway Premiere

Solea Pfeiffer and the cast of 'Wanted' (Julieta Cervantes)
Solea Pfeiffer and the cast of Wanted (Julieta Cervantes)

With Angelica Chéri as the book writer and lyricist, and Ross Baum’s music, the original, profound and spectacular musical Wanted resonates with themes for today. Wanted, directed by Stevie Walker-Webb, and based on a true story set in Texas, 1893, currently runs at the James Earl Jones Theater until Mach 31, 2027.

Chéri, grew up with stories about her ancestors, the Clarke twins, Mary and Martha, (portrayed by the brilliant Solea Pfeiffer and Liiisi LaFontaine). Entrepreneurial Black women who pass for white, the twins help their mama Tallulah (an equally brilliant Ledisi) raise rent money for the extortionate cotton plantation owner Mr. Billingsly (Nathan Quay Thomas). Arrogantly insulting the twins, he gives them the idea they look white enough to “pass.” Thus, begins their outlawing, by holding up unsuspecting whites on their own turf (“Wide Open Plains,” “The Train,” “Just Passing Through,” “Gun & Powder”). Because they cleverly dupe their bigoted “victims” using their own racism against them, they avoid getting caught.

With irony, the resulting karma delights. Indeed, they deservedly turn the tables on a hateful, sadistic culure of white supremacists who’ve robbed, tortured and enslaved Blacks for generations. Also, they elicit the audience’s sympathy and laughter especially when their mother gives them a gun (without bullets), a blessin,g and exhortation to take the white folks’ money. Certainly, it’s a recompense and vindcation for their ancestors’ enslavement and abuse.

However, a “wanted poster circulates,” advertising a reward for their capture. Underlying the conceit of “passing,” the facts speak in a whisper. If the truth of their Black blood get outs and the “law” apprehends them, most probably despite their beauty, the supremacists will torture and lynch them without a trial. Clearly, that secret revealed will get them killed, not just jailed for robbery.

Luke James, Liisi LaFontaine in 'Wanted' (Julieta Cervantes)
Luke James, Liisi LaFontaine in Wanted (Julieta Cervantes)

Thus, the power of their blood and legacy is a two-edged sword. Not only does it bless them with the freedom and audacity to live as whites away from their home. Also, it curses them under the wrong circumstances. Whether one views them as reckless and foolharty or wise as a serpent harmless as a dove, they valiantly, heroically turn the corrupt system against itself. After all, slavery and oppression was predicated on the historical “one drop rule.” For example Jim Crow Louisana held that even if an individual had a drop of Black blood ancestry, i.e. 1/32nd, that person was Black and subject to laws of oppression. What they “do” to the Southern white culture of the entrenched “lost Confederacy” is a blasphemy and they are doubly dangerous to it by passing.

Nevertheless, they continue with their faith and luck following a rumor about a wealthy saloonkeeper who has gold. When they meet Jesse (the excellent Bradley Jaden), he recognzes them from their “wanted” poster. However, Cupid shoots his arrow. Jesse falls hard for Mary and saves them from being apprehended. Meanwhile, Jesse lures Martha and Mary with a luxurious hotel room and lifestyle, and treats them like royalty.

Problematically, when he gives them into the care of Black servants Sissy (Aurelia Williams) and Flo (Awa Sal Secka), the servants easily know Martha and Mary’s identity. In “Dangerous” they reveal the extent to which the passing women rebel against Jesse, the culture and system of oppression. Williams and Sal Secka display the passion of sheltered truth, not only with their powerful voices, their comedic authenticity wins the audience with belly laughs.

On a deeper level, Martha understands the jeopardy hovering over them. If Mary deludeds herself with Jesse’s wealth and power that he extends to her with a marriage proposal, Martha counts the costs and makes plans. In discussing this with Jesse’s servant Elijah (the exceptional Luke James) who notes Martha’s jealousy, Martha clarifies and corrects him. Prayerfully, she believes in her sister’s inner conviction to never renounce her blood legacy of truth and faith, as the seed of Tallulah Clark. Consequentially, Martha refuses to accept that her sister loves Jesse enough to live an artificial life as a white woman.

The cast of 'Wanted' (Julieta Cervantes)
The cast of Wanted (Julieta Cervantes)

When Mary considers her identity (“The Way I Am”), she powders her face and powders her mother’s face which haunts her in the mirror. This staging genius by Walker-Webb symbolizes her cowardly “whitewashing” of her identity, the truth, her heritage and her faith. When she takes off a locket of her ancestry her mother gave her, she chooses. The themes Chéri and Baum highlight move from racial identity to issues of feminism, wealth, status and power. How much of herself must Mary give up to be Jesse’s wife?

As an imperative, Martha focuses not on romance with Elijah, as delicious as he is. Instead, she resolves to shake her sister loose from a path which will destroy not only Mary, but her mother, herself and their legacy. In a poweful moment (“Trigger”) Martha effects the plan which will eventually redeem Mary and their mother who has written to her daughters for help. After Tallulah paid off Billingley with her daughers’ outlaw money, enraged, he extorts her for more. In order to save her from a jail sentence and complete impoverishment and eviction from Billingsly’s place, they must return home.

Turning her back on her faith, identity and famly, Mary convinces herself that Jesse’s love for her will accept all of her, even her family. However, Martha knows the secret about Jesse’s inheritance. Martha holds their family’s fate down the barrel of her mother’s gun. And by the end off Act I, Martha, dressed like an outlaw in black, the opposite of Mary in a white wedding dress, shoots Jesse.

The cast of 'Wanted;' (Julieta Cervantes)
The cast of Wanted (Julieta Cervantes)

The resolutions of the conflicts and the exploration of themes happens in a “dangerous” Act II. Regardless, of the satisfying conclusion uplifting the legacy of this family and their faith, one remembers Mary’s recklessness, prompted by childhood abandondment by her white father. Her love for Jesse like her mother’s love for a Frenchman, who left her with the twins, was doomed before. Interracial marriage (miscegenation) was a crime that only became legal with the ruling in Loving v. Virginia (1967). It is no wonder Jesse threatens her life when he finds out her true identity.

Clearly, in Wanted, Chéri creates her own spin on her now famous aunts whose outlawing lifted them and their mother from poverty and oppression to autonomy and self-determination. Because Chéri deals with folklore as legacy, she selects an ensemble of ancestral spirit guardians to set up the tone of the musical in the prologue. These “kinfolk,” dressed in filmy, angelic, outfits (Emilio Sosa’s costume design) acknowledge the Lord (the Clarke family rely on their faith in God and love for each other). Through their perspective, they bridge the scenes in the past with summary in song, (“The Train,” “Gun and Powder,” “The Shot That Shook the Soul,” “Enough”). Thus, we understand the Clarke story in flashback through a fanciful, adventurous, exciting lens. In the “Prologue,” they sing, “You know how family stories do, so we believe it’s mostly true.”

In effect, the shifting atmosphere and mood of various scenes that have whimsical, farcical elements, should be viewed as the stuff of legend, more like an instructional story to edify and uplift. If one picks apart the tale, looking closely, one will note contradictions, gaps in information and a bit of revisionist history. However, considering some governors in the South today have rewritten slavery’s horrific torments as gentle edification, if acknowledging lynchings ever, Chéri’s account about her aunts seems entirely just. Importantly, Chéri conveys the memes around the oppressive, killing cotton plantations, remnants that continued with peonage into the 1950s.

Not only is the musical imagistic with visually striking, beautiful, background projections (Stefania Bulbarella), Beowulf Boritt’s rustic wooden timbers in a stylized set design conveys time and plac. The supercharged emotional singing of the terrific ensemble energizes and soars in anointed power. With a variety of music throughout including gospel, spirituals, R & B, pop, and a little bit of country, Chéri and Baum engage the passionate thematic through-line. To establish one’s legacy, one must embrace one’s true identity with unflinching courage.

Wanted runs 2 hours 30 minutes with one intermission at the James Earl Jones Theater through March 31, 2027. wantedmusical.com.

Unknown's avatar

About caroleditosti

Carole Di Tosti, Ph.D. is an Entertainment Journalist (Broadway, Off Broadway, Drama Desk voter) novelist, poet and playwright. Carole Di Tosti has over 1800 articles, reviews, sonnets and other online writings, all of which appear on her website: https://caroleditostibooks.com Carole Di Tosti writes for Blogcritics.com, Sandi Durell's Theater Pizzazz and other New York theater websites. Carole Di Tost free-lanced for VERVE and wrote for Technorati for 2 years. Some of the articles are archived. Carole Di Tosti covers premiere film festivals in the NY area:: Tribeca FF, NYFF, DOC NYC, Hamptons IFF, NYJewish FF, Athena FF. She also covered SXSW until 2020. Carole Di Tosti's novel 'Peregrine: The Ceremony of Powers' was released in 2021. Her poetry book 'Light Shifts' was released in 2021. 'The Berglarian,' a comedy in two acts was released in 2023.

Posted on November 16, 2026, in Broadway and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.